Benebone vs Nylabone – Which Dog Chew Toy is best for your Pet?

As a dog owner, finding the right chew toy for my Golden Retriever has been a bit of trial and error. I started with a Nylabone when my dog was still a puppy, and it worked well at first—especially since Nylabone offers softer options for young dogs. However, once my dog grew and became a more aggressive chewer, I noticed the toy wasn’t holding up as well. That’s when I tried a Benebone based on recommendations from other dog owners. The flavor infusion and durable design were a hit with my dog, and it lasted much longer than the previous toys. This led me to dig deeper into the comparison between Benebone vs Nylabone to find out which one would ultimately be the better choice for different chewing needs.

Overview: Benebone vs Nylabone

When it comes to durable dog chew toys, Benebone and Nylabone are two of the most well-known brands. Both offer a variety of options designed to withstand different levels of chewing, but there are key differences in their design, material, and flavor options that may sway your decision.

Which one lasts longer?

When comparing Benebone and Nylabone, durability is a key factor, especially if you have an aggressive chewer. Both toys are made of tough nylon, but they are designed with different chewing intensities in mind.

• Benebone toys are designed for aggressive chewers and are made of nylon infused with real flavors like bacon, chicken, or peanut butter. They are sturdy and last for weeks or even months, depending on the dog’s chewing intensity.
• Nylabone offers different durability levels, ranging from softer chews for puppies or light chewers to ultra-durable options for aggressive chewers. The material is equally tough, but the choice of hardness levels gives pet owners more flexibility.

Pro Tip:

If your dog is an extreme chewer, both brands offer high-durability versions, but Benebone is often considered better suited for very aggressive chewers due to its thicker, sturdier design.

Flavor Options: What does your Dog prefer?

One of the reasons dogs love chew toys is for their flavor, and both Benebone and Nylabone excel in offering a variety of flavors.

• Benebone infuses their chew toys with real meat flavors, which can make them more enticing to picky chewers. The flavors are strong and last for the life of the toy.
• Nylabone, on the other hand, offers a wider variety of flavors, including bacon, chicken, beef, and peanut butter. This can give your dog more options and make it easier to find a flavor they love.

Aggressive Chewers vs Moderate Chewers

Every dog has a different chewing style, and it’s essential to choose a toy that matches your pet’s chewing habits.

Are Benebone & Nylabone safe?

Safety is a major concern for pet owners, especially with chew toys that might splinter or break off in pieces.

• Benebone emphasizes that its toys are non-edible and should be replaced once they become worn or if any pieces break off.
• Nylabone also offers non-edible chews, but the company provides different levels of toughness to prevent small fragments from breaking off, especially with softer versions for puppies or light chewers.

Safety Tip:

Always choose a chew toy size that’s appropriate for your dog to avoid choking hazards. Both brands recommend that dogs be supervised while chewing.

Size and Shape Variety

Both Benebone and Nylabone offer a variety of sizes and shapes to keep your dog entertained.

• Benebone is well-known for its wishbone shape, which is easy for dogs to grip and chew. They also offer dental chews and stick shapes that mimic natural chewing motions.
• Nylabone offers a wider range of shapes, including the traditional bone, rings, and dental chews designed to clean your dog’s teeth while they play.

Which is better for Puppies?

Puppies require softer chew toys, as their teeth are not fully developed. Both brands offer options suitable for younger dogs.

• Benebone offers a specific puppy line of softer chews that are less likely to damage a young dog’s teeth.
• Nylabone has a variety of puppy chew toys specifically designed to be softer for teething, including teething rings and bones.

Cost and Value for Money

When it comes to cost, both Benebone and Nylabone are similarly priced, though Nylabone offers a wider range of prices based on size and durability.

While Benebone tends to be a bit pricier, it often lasts longer for aggressive chewers, making it a good investment. Nylabone offers more budget-friendly options, especially for moderate chewers or puppies.

Conclusion: Benebone or Nylabone?

After trying both Benebone and Nylabone over the years with my dog, I can confidently say that each brand has its strengths depending on the situation. The Benebone has become my go-to for my dog’s long chewing sessions because of its flavor and durability, but Nylabone still offers great variety, especially for teething puppies or dogs with less intense chewing habits. Personally, the Benebone worked best for my dog’s powerful chewing, but if you have a younger or less aggressive chewer, Nylabone’s wide range of options may suit your dog better. In the end, both brands have their place in a dog’s toy collection, depending on their chewing style and stage of life.

In summary:

• Choose Benebone if your dog is an aggressive chewer and prefers stronger meat flavors.
• Choose Nylabone if your dog is a moderate chewer, or if you’re looking for a wider range of flavors and shapes.

FAQs